who would you choose (teens only)

Girl 1- brunette, me and her share a lot in common, good looking, smart, seems to like me a lot but talks to other boys a lot- maybe too often. Girl 2- equally good looking as 1 but better body, blonde, seems to like me but a little less than 1, seems smart, shy but not afraid to talk to me. i think i might like 1 better than 2 but not sure- thats y i ask